Änderungsprotokoll
Jede Datenaktualisierung, Korrektur und Methodikänderung wird hier und in der Änderungshistorie jeder Klinik festgehalten. Das Rating wird aktualisiert, sobald sich die zugrunde liegenden öffentlichen Daten ändern.
| Datum | Betreff | Änderung |
|---|---|---|
| 2026-09-03 | Methodik v1.3.1 | Clarified that the publication criteria refer to the clinic’s own channels: a service list, the names of the dentists and a price list count when the clinic itself publishes them (its website, its social profiles or its own Google Business profile) — registers, directories and review sites do not, and a time-limited promotional offer is not a price list. Added a third state for a dentist’s licence, "checked, not found in the public register": a dentist we searched for in the national register and did not find is now recorded as checked-but-unverified with the date of the check, instead of being shown either as "not checked yet" or as the "not published" red flag. Neither change alters any weight or penalty; the red-flag rule still fires only on a verified negative. Also corrected the wording of the penalty note under the ranking table, which rendered as "20−" in right-to-left dictionaries. |
| 2026-08-25 | 62LTM / Dr Karim Dada | Re-verification 2026-08-25: the original '62LTM' listing at the on-file address (Boulevard de la Tour-Maubourg, 75007 Paris, same phone) shows 'Permanently closed' on Google Maps. Dr. Karim Dada now practices at a new address, 8 Rue Guy de Maupassant, 75116 Paris, with a new practice website (dr-dada-karim.chirurgiens-dentistes.fr); phone unchanged (+33 1 42 88 40 81); the original leadingimplantcenters.com profile page is still live as a bio/profile page. Updated address and website fields to the new location. Captured Google rating 5.0 (70 reviews), geo coordinates and Maps URL at the new address. Sedation research: no anaesthesia/sedation information found on the current practice site (academic publications by Dr. Dada reference general anaesthesia/MEOPA sedation in implant-surgery literature generally, but this was not confirmed as offered directly by his own clinic, so left unset). |
| 2026-08-25 | 62LTM / Dr Karim Dada | License verification 2026-08-25 against ONCD annuaire: both named doctors (Karim Dada, Dorothee Louis-Olszewski) found with matching RPPS numbers, corroborated by older-format Ordre numbers published on the clinic's own mentions-legales page; registry still shows their former Tour-Maubourg address rather than the current Rue Guy de Maupassant location. FINESS not applicable (liberal cabinet, not a centre de sante); clinic's own site shows only a commercial SIRET/RCS. |
| 2026-08-25 | Docteur Vimazal | Re-verification 2026-08-25: confirmed website live, address, phone unchanged, clinic open. Newly captured Google rating 4.6 (35 reviews), geo coordinates and Maps URL (previously unset). Sedation research: no anaesthesia/sedation information found on the clinic site. |
| 2026-08-25 | Docteur Vimazal | License verification 2026-08-25 against ONCD annuaire: Dr Silviya Vimazal found, RPPS 10005224091, Liberal, address matches exactly. FINESS not applicable (solo liberal cabinet). |
| 2026-08-25 | Dr Hans Dindoyal | Re-verification 2026-08-25: website (live, 2026 copyright) and Instagram (posts as recent as April 2026) both active; address/phone unchanged. However Google Maps currently flags the profile 'Temporarily closed' (not 'Permanently closed') — likely a seasonal August closure given the otherwise active site/social presence and an owner review-response dated 3 months ago; recommend re-checking after August. Google rating changed 4.5/28 to current 4.6/59; captured geo coordinates and Maps URL. Sedation research: site's pre-op instructions and wisdom-tooth page state extraction is done 'sous anesthésie locale ou générale' — general anaesthesia is documented as offered. |
| 2026-08-25 | Dr Hans Dindoyal | Recorded sedation / general anaesthesia availability (informational): documented as available. Wisdom-tooth extraction documented as done under local or general anaesthesia |
| 2026-08-25 | Dr Hans Dindoyal | License verification 2026-08-25 against ONCD annuaire: Dr Hans Dindoyal found, RPPS 10100252518, Liberal, address matches exactly. FINESS not applicable (solo liberal cabinet). |
| 2026-08-25 | Dr Patrick Bauer | Re-verification 2026-08-25: website live, address/phone unchanged, clinic open (matched listing 'Dentiste | Bauer Patrick' at the confirmed address and phone). Google rating/review count differ substantially from stale stored values (4.1/164 to current 4.8/23) — flagging the large review-count drop for editorial awareness, as it may reflect a listing change on Google's side rather than a data error here; captured geo coordinates and Maps URL. Sedation research: no anaesthesia/sedation information found on the clinic site. |
| 2026-08-25 | Dr Patrick Bauer | License verification 2026-08-25 against ONCD annuaire: Dr Patrick Bauer found, RPPS 10000083906, Liberal, address matches exactly (despite site's claim of a New York State dental diploma, he is separately registered with the French Ordre). FINESS not applicable (solo liberal cabinet). |
| 2026-08-25 | Dr Phoebe Kamioner | Re-verification 2026-08-25: confirmed website live, address, phone unchanged, clinic open. Newly captured Google rating 4.4 (111 reviews), geo coordinates and Maps URL (previously unset). Sedation research: site's extraction page states wisdom-tooth extraction 'peut être réalisée sous anesthésie locale ou générale en fonction des cas' — general anaesthesia documented as an option; standard extractions are local-anaesthesia only. |
| 2026-08-25 | Dr Phoebe Kamioner | Recorded sedation / general anaesthesia availability (informational): documented as available. Wisdom-tooth extraction documented as available under local or general anaesthesia depending on case difficulty; standard extractions are local-only |
| 2026-08-25 | Dr Phoebe Kamioner | License verification 2026-08-25 against ONCD annuaire: Dr Phoebe Kamioner found, RPPS 10107326166, Liberal, address matches exactly. FINESS not applicable (liberal cabinet). |
| 2026-08-25 | La Smile Clinic | Re-verification 2026-08-25: smile-clinic.fr now returns a permanent 301 redirect to cabinet-dentaire-madeleine.com, whose homepage self-identifies as 'Cabinet Dentaire de la Madeleine (formerly Smile Clinic Paris)' — La Smile Clinic has been rebranded/merged into The Madeleine Dental Practice at the same on-file address and phone (8 Boulevard de la Madeleine, 75009 Paris, +33 1 40 70 95 64). Updated website field to the new URL. Matched Google Maps listing 'Le Cabinet Dentaire de la Madeleine | Paris' (4.8, 282 reviews) whose reviews explicitly reference both 'The Smile Clinic Paris' and current staff, confirming continuity; captured geo/Maps URL. Sedation research: site states wisdom-tooth extraction is done under local anaesthesia only ('réalisée sous anesthésie locale') — no GA/deep sedation documented. |
| 2026-08-25 | La Smile Clinic | Recorded sedation / general anaesthesia availability (informational): not documented in public sources. Wisdom-tooth extraction documented as done under local anaesthesia only; no GA/deep sedation mentioned (site now merged into cabinet-dentaire-madeleine.com) |
| 2026-08-25 | La Smile Clinic | License verification 2026-08-25 against ONCD annuaire: all 3 named doctors (Badaoui, Nammour, Lucas) found with matching RPPS numbers and exact clinic address. FINESS clinic-establishment search could not be completed (SPA requires browser session, unavailable this session); clinic's own mentions-legales shows only a commercial RCS number for SELARL MONTAIGNE TREMOILLE. |
| 2026-08-25 | Methodik v1.3.0 | Corrected how the two licensing red flags are applied ("Clinic operating licence not published" and "Dentists / their licences not listed"). Previously they were applied whenever licensing data was absent from our records, which treated unchecked data as a negative finding — contrary to the methodology's own rule that unverified data is a fact about our coverage, not about the clinic. Both flags now apply only where we have verified that the information is not published. Manual licensing flags that rested on unverified data were removed from the affected clinics. No other scoring rules changed; most scores rise because the incorrect penalty is removed. |
| 2026-08-25 | Paris Dental Studios | Re-verification 2026-08-25: confirmed website live, address, phone unchanged, clinic open. Google rating changed from stale 4.7/348 to current 4.6/440; captured geo coordinates and Maps URL. Sedation research: site documents general anaesthesia only as reserved for specific cases (e.g. child dental phobia) with local anaesthesia recommended generally, plus light IV sedation for implants — does not meet the sleep-dentistry bar. |
| 2026-08-25 | Paris Dental Studios | Recorded sedation / general anaesthesia availability (informational): not documented in public sources. GA reserved for specific cases (e.g. child dental phobia); local anaesthesia recommended generally for extractions; light IV sedation offered for implants only |
| 2026-08-25 | Paris Dental Studios | License verification 2026-08-25 against FINESS (clinics) and clinic's own mentions-legales: FINESS search API blocked (SPA needs session/XSRF token, no browser this session); clinic site publishes only a commercial SIREN, no dental establishment license; no individual dentist names published on-site so no ONCD doctor search was possible. |
| 2026-08-25 | Sana Oris | Re-verification 2026-08-25: website live. Sana Oris operates multiple Paris locations (Paris 08 Roosevelt: 53 Av. Franklin Delano Roosevelt, 4.6/817 reviews; Paris 04 Marais: 13 Rue Jean Beausire, 4.7/658 reviews; plus Sana Oris Kids). Filled previously-blank address/phone/geo with the flagship Paris 08 (Roosevelt) location; the Marais location exists as an alternate if a second location card is wanted. Captured Google rating 4.6 (817 reviews), geo coordinates and Maps URL. Sedation research: site FAQ ('Oui, nous proposons l'anesthésie générale') confirms general anaesthesia is offered, via partnership, for complex/implant surgery, though not performed on-site for routine wisdom-tooth extraction. |
| 2026-08-25 | Sana Oris | Recorded sedation / general anaesthesia availability (informational): documented as available. General anaesthesia offered via partnership for complex/implant surgery; not performed on-site for routine wisdom-tooth extraction |
| 2026-08-25 | Sana Oris | License verification 2026-08-25 against ONCD annuaire: Dr Umberto Russo found, RPPS 10102084729, Liberal, registered at the group's Marais (75004) site rather than the on-file Roosevelt (75008) address. FINESS search could not be completed (SPA requires browser session, unavailable this session); own mentions-legales shows only a commercial RCS number, no health-establishment license. |
| 2026-08-25 | The Madeleine Dental Practice | Re-verification 2026-08-25: website live at cabinet-dentaire-madeleine.com, address/phone unchanged, clinic open. This entity is now the merged practice absorbing 'La Smile Clinic' (smile-clinic.fr permanently redirects here; the site itself says 'formerly Smile Clinic Paris'). Newly captured Google rating 4.8 (282 reviews), geo coordinates and Maps URL. Sedation research: site states wisdom-tooth extraction is done under local anaesthesia only — no GA/deep sedation documented. |
| 2026-08-25 | The Madeleine Dental Practice | Recorded sedation / general anaesthesia availability (informational): not documented in public sources. Wisdom-tooth extraction documented as done under local anaesthesia only; no GA/deep sedation mentioned |
| 2026-08-25 | The Madeleine Dental Practice | License verification 2026-08-25 against ONCD annuaire: all 12 named doctors found with matching RPPS numbers; 11 of 12 match the clinic address exactly, one (Dr Joseph Dardas) matches on name+specialty but the registry lists a different Paris address (44 Bd de Reuilly, 75012) -- flagged for human review rather than marked false. FINESS clinic-establishment search could not be completed (SPA requires browser session, unavailable this session); mentions-legales shows only a commercial RCS number for SELARL MONTAIGNE TREMOILLE. |
| 2026-08-25 | ZAGA Center Paris / Smile24h | Re-verification 2026-08-25: smile24h.com confirms it is a network/platform, not a single clinic ('Smile24h is not a clinic. We are a global network of dental professionals'); ZAGA Center Paris operates through the Sana Oris clinic group, confirmed via Sana Oris's own Instagram post ('ZAGA CENTER PARIS ... Certified Center of Zygomatic Excellence 2026') and LinkedIn. Replaced the vague on-file address with the Sana Oris Paris 8 flagship location (53 Av. Franklin Delano Roosevelt, 75008 Paris) and captured its phone. Captured Google rating 4.6 (817 reviews), geo coordinates and Maps URL for this location. Sedation research: Sana Oris's site FAQ states general anaesthesia is offered, via partnership, for complex/implant surgery (the zygomatic/full-arch work ZAGA Center specializes in), though not performed on-site for routine wisdom-tooth extraction. |
| 2026-08-25 | ZAGA Center Paris / Smile24h | Recorded sedation / general anaesthesia availability (informational): documented as available. General anaesthesia offered via partnership for complex/implant (zygomatic/full-arch) surgery; not performed on-site for routine wisdom-tooth extraction |
| 2026-08-25 | ZAGA Center Paris / Smile24h | License verification 2026-08-25 against ONCD annuaire: Dr Umberto Russo found, RPPS 10102084729, Liberal, registered at Sana Oris's Marais (75004) location rather than the on-file Roosevelt (75008) address -- consistent with Sana Oris operating multiple Paris sites. FINESS not searchable (SPA requires browser session, unavailable this session); ZAGA Center itself is a referral network with no separate French establishment registration. |
| 2026-08-23 | Methodik v1.2.0 | Added an informational "Sedation & general anaesthesia" availability field to every clinic and a new "Sleep Dentistry (Sedation / GA)" list, for patients who cannot tolerate — or would rather not be awake for — treatment. This field is informational and does not change any transparency score. |
| 2026-07-08 | 62LTM / Dr Karim Dada | Initial data collection. |
| 2026-07-08 | Docteur Vimazal | Initial data collection. |
| 2026-07-08 | Dr Hans Dindoyal | Initial data collection. |
| 2026-07-08 | Dr Patrick Bauer | Initial data collection. |
| 2026-07-08 | Dr Phoebe Kamioner | Initial data collection. |
| 2026-07-08 | La Smile Clinic | Initial data collection. |
| 2026-07-08 | Methodik v1.1.0 | Added licensing transparency: clinics are now penalised when they do not publish their operating licence, or do not list their dentists together with their professional licence numbers. Each clinic page now shows a Licensing & Credentials section. |
| 2026-07-08 | Paris Dental Studios | Initial data collection. |
| 2026-07-08 | Sana Oris | Initial data collection. |
| 2026-07-08 | The Madeleine Dental Practice | Initial data collection. |
| 2026-07-08 | ZAGA Center Paris / Smile24h | Initial data collection. |
| 2026-07-03 | Methodik v1.0.0 | Initial public methodology. |